Top MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Cards and Lineups for March 2025

The highly anticipated release of MLB The Show 25 marks the triumphant return of the ever-popular Diamond Dynasty mode. Players can dive into the world of baseball by collecting cards featuring their favorite current players and legendary icons to craft the ultimate lineup. As of March 2025, here are some of the best MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty cards and recommended lineups.

Best Diamond Dynasty Cards in MLB The Show 25

Team Affinity James Wood

The rising star of the Washington Nationals, James Wood, is the Team Affinity reward for this season. While unlocking him may require some effort, his impressive batting skills against both left- and right-handed pitchers make him a valuable addition. His substantial power as a corner outfielder ensures he’ll fit seamlessly into the heart of your lineup.

Pipeline Program Walker Jenkins

Although Walker Jenkins is primarily a center fielder, his bat is so potent that it’s worth placing him elsewhere in the lineup. With excellent contact and power stats, he can deliver crucial hits despite his average speed. Expect him to surprise opponents with timely runs.

20th Anniversary Clayton Kershaw

A staple in MLB The Show for over a decade, Clayton Kershaw makes his debut in MLB The Show 25 as part of the Anniversary Series. His arsenal of pitches includes his iconic 12-6 Curveball, making him a formidable force on the mound. Plus, his affordability ensures even budget-conscious players can enjoy his talents.

Live Series Emmanuel Clase

As relief pitching takes center stage in Diamond Dynasty, Emmanuel Clase shines with his exceptional card. Though his pitch selection isn’t overwhelming, his high-speed fastball and devastating slider dominate hitters. Assign him as your closer and watch the opposition crumble.

Best March 2025 MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Lineup

Confidence is key when entering ranked games in Diamond Dynasty. Below is a well-rounded lineup featuring realistically attainable cards, excluding premium options like Live Series Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani.

• Shortstop: 20th Anniversary Elly De La Cruz
• Left Field: Pipeline Program Walker Jenkins
• Third Base: Prospect Pipeline Jordan Lawlar
• Right Field: Team Affinity James Wood
• Center Field: Spring Breakout Max Clark
• Designated Hitter: 20th Anniversary David Wright
• Catcher: Team Affinity Craig Biggio
• Second Base: Spring Breakout JJ Wetherholt
• First Base: Prospect Pipeline Nick Kurtz
• Starting Pitcher: 20th Anniversary Clayton Kershaw
• Relief Pitcher: Live Series Felix Bautista
• Closer: Live Series Emmanuel Clase

These cards and lineups represent the cream of the crop in MLB The Show 25’s Diamond Dynasty mode for March 2025. For more insights, check out whether going to college or turning pro aligns better with your Road to the Show aspirations.

MLB The Show 25 is currently available in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.